• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Recipes
    • Recipes
      • Pies + tarts
      • Brownies + bars
      • Cakes + cupcakes
      • Cocktails + drinks
      • Ice cream
      • Breakfast + brunch
  • About me
  • In your kitchen
  • services
  • Family life
  • My friends

Kate the baker

menu icon
go to homepage
  • Recipes
  • Meet Kate
  • In Your Kitchen
  • Services
  • My friends
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • Pinterest
  • subscribe
    search icon
    Homepage link
    • Recipes
    • Meet Kate
    • In Your Kitchen
    • Services
    • My friends
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • Pinterest
  • ×
    Home » Pies + tarts

    Published: Jul 9, 2020 · Modified: Nov 17, 2020 by Katie Beck · 6 Comments

    Butterscotch pie

    I am here to introduce you to what is probably my favorite non fruit pie - butterscotch pie. For some reason butterscotch pie is a summer thing. It probably really isn't, but to me it is.

    Butterscotch pie goes hand in hand with bbq to me, which goes hand in hand with summer. Maybe it is because it is similar in flavor to the buttery chess pie that the South is famous (and bbq goes with the south to me also).

    What is butterscotch?

    Butterscotch is basically cooked brown sugar and butter, and then hitting it with cream and vanilla. It has a deeper richer flavor than caramel and is definitely less cloyingly sweet. I usually find that people are either butterscotch or caramel people...I am butterscotch. I just prefer the deeper flavor.

    What makes this butterscotch pie better than the rest?

    This butterscotch pie is probably a little different that what you will find in a general search for a recipe. Most are cooked custard / pudding pies. This is not that kind of pie. This is a baked custard, and it is deinitely my preference. Think pumpkin pie without the pumpkin. Creamy and smooth but not thick and cold.

    If the cold custard is your jam, I think you should try a pudding pie and compare. Here is a stove top cooked custard butterscotch pie I have made a few times before settling on the baked kind as my fave. The texture is definitely different, and I am always interest in what draws people to different things.

    And if you are looking for something all together different from a pie, but still butterscotch and quite possibly the greatest dessert ever, look no further than my butterscotch budino, here. You will not be sorry (full disclosure this is one of my first recipes before my photography skills blossomed. The pics are not the best but I promise you this is one of my best recipes).

    What really sets my butterscotch pie apart is BROWNING THE BUTTER. This kind of adds a nutty element to the whole pie and cuts the sweetness a bit, cause I mean, this is basically a sugar pie, any other element is welcome.

    Butterscotch pie

    No ratings yet
    Print Recipe Pin Recipe

    Ingredients
      

    • ¾ cup unsalted butter
    • 2 cups dark brown sugar
    • ¾ teaspoon kosher or sea salt
    • 1 cup 160 ml heavy cream, cold
    • 1 tablespoon vanilla bean paste or use 1 ½ teaspoon of vanilla extract
    • 7 eggs
    • Your favorite recipe pie crust formed into a pie plate and prebaked

    Instructions
     

    • Preheat oven to 375.
    • In a heavy saucepan melt the butter. Continue cooking butter until it is bubbly and you begin to see browned bits on the bottom. The bubbling will subside a bit when it is ready. Then make sure the heat is on low. When the butter is browned, add the brown sugar and salt, whisk about two minutes to combine, it will not be a smooth mixture, that is ok. Pull from the heat and immediately and SLOWLY whisk in the heavy cream and continue whisking until fully incorporated.
    • Let it sit for about 20 minutes or so off the stovetop and then add your eggs one at a time, whisking like crazy after adding each egg. Add the vanilla last.
    • Pour the butterscotch mixture into the prebaked pie crust and bake at 375 for 10 minutes ONLY! Then turn the oven down to 300 (this will ensure a smooth and not dry custard) and continue to bake for 30 more minutes - maybe a touch more. It will be a little jiggly in the center, but only barely.
    • Cool this completely before serving. I am not a fridge fan for this pie (nor am I for pumpkin pie), but my family def prefers this cold, so do what you like. Definitley doesn't hurt to serve with unsweetened (that's right, the pie is sweet enough) whipped cream on the top.
    Tried this recipe?Let us know how it was!

    Looking for other great recipes with butterscotch? Check out my butterscotch banana bread here.

    More Pies + tarts

    • Whole tomato quiche in a pie plate with tomatoes and basil.
      Tomato quiche with balsamic caramelized onions
    • Slice of old fashioned lemon pie on stacked plates with whipped cream and a lemon slice.
      Old fashioned lemon pie
    • Closeup overhead view of a nutella tart with roasted hazelnuts.
      Nutella tart with roasted hazelnuts
    • A pumpkin share recipe with leftover pumpkin pie is the perfect milkshake.
      Pumpkin shake recipe - with leftover pumpkin pie

    Reader Interactions

    Comments

    1. Nat says

      July 16, 2020 at 5:48 am

      I cheated and bought pie dough from the store. The dough became soggy when baking the custard filling (despite pre-baking crust @ 400°F for 10 minutes). Some filling spilled over crust so that may have been the culprit. Next time I'd try tart dough or maybe even a graham cracker crust. Heed her advice & mix eggs well or you'll have white bits like mine! I liked the flavor but the texture was too eggy for my preference. Thanks for the recipe! https://imgur.com/gallery/jIUT2Oc

      Reply
    2. Chef Sharon says

      August 10, 2020 at 8:42 pm

      One tablespoon of what?? There’s not an ingredient next to it.

      Reply
      • kwalsh0722 says

        August 10, 2020 at 9:21 pm

        Vanilla bean paste (or use 1 1/2 teaspoons of extract). Thank you! I have fixed this now!

        Reply
    3. Sharon says

      August 12, 2020 at 6:01 pm

      This pie was a hit at my house! I had to bake it longer than your recipe stated and it seems too jiggly, but when it was all said and done it was delicious! Thanks for sharing your recipe and I'm sure I'll make it again. I made it in a homemade gluten-free pie crust (my oldest son is celiac) and he LOVED it. I'm sure I'll make it again. Thanks for your help on the missing measurement. Isn't it funny how something like that slips past us?

      Reply
    4. Tiffany says

      September 19, 2020 at 8:49 am

      This looks amazing and perfect for the fall weather! Can’t wait to have a go at this recipe. Thanks xx

      Tiffany
      Phlanx's Marketing Specialist

      Reply
    5. Coffee Shops Nearby says

      October 11, 2020 at 12:57 pm

      Very valuable information, it is not at all blogs that we find this, congratulations I was looking for something like that and found it here.

      King regards,
      Abildgaard Griffin

      Reply

    Tell me whatcha think Cancel reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    Recipe Rating




    Primary Sidebar

    Hi, I'm Kate! My mission is to bring life to amazing food and recipes with a few tips and humorous stories (and a few swears) about life with a big, loud and crazy family. My recipes are accessible, adaptable and designed for any home cook to prepare and enjoy.

    More about me →

    My favorite recipes

    • overhead view of a plate of Maggiano's rigatoni d.
      Rigatoni d (just like Maggiano's)
    • overhead view of a bowl of irish seafodd chowder with a spoon.
      Irish seafood chowder
    • Maple syrup poured into a maple bourbon cocktail
      Maple Bourbon Cocktail
    • Slice of old fashioned lemon pie on stacked plates with whipped cream and a lemon slice.
      Old fashioned lemon pie

    Never miss a thing

    Sign Up!
    Subscribe and get my once a month email with tips and additional recipes!

    December favorites

    • Slice of salted caramel mocha cheesecake with fudge drizzle on a plate
      Salted caramel mocha cheesecake
    • slice of chocolate macadamia nut tart on a plate
      Chocolate Macadamia Nut Tart
    • A closeup of whole matcha cookie in a hand.
      Matcha cookies
    • Candy Cane White Russian and a couple of drunk elves

    Footer

    ↑ back to top

    About

    • Privacy Policy
    • Recipe Index

    Newsletter

    • Sign Up! for emails and updates

    Contact

    • Services
    • Meet Kate

    Copyright © 2023 Kate The Baker